Why Does My Horse Still Have This Problem? [Horse Pulling]


Your horse is a living, breathing thing with emotions, desires, strengths and weaknesses. And while he may be trained to your liking today, keeping him there is going to take consistency on your part. By the same token, if your horse has a problem today then its “inconsistency” that might have got you there.

Here’s inconsistency: You pick up the rein. Your horse tugs back and you think to yourself “Oh, I just don’t feel like dealing with it today.” Bang! You’ve just taught your horse that some days he can get away with pulling on you. Now he’ll begin testing you. Every day he’ll pull to see if maybe this is the day he can get away with a little more. A seed has been planted. A little problem grows into a big headache.

Here’s consistency: You pick up the rein. Your horse tugs back. You take the time to hold onto that rein until the horse softens and gives. (You might also want to apply a little extra motivation at that moment like increasing the speed, disengaging the hips, adding a bit of pressure, etc.) You respond this way each and every time, 24/7, 365 days per year.

It’s your job to be consistent simply because horses become mirror images of their owners. Let’s say you buy a horse and the horse pulls on the bit like he’s trying to rip your arms out of their sockets. Well, you can blame the previous owner for that behavior for only about three months. That’s it. Three months. After that, it’s your fault because three months is enough time to change your horse if you’re being consistent and truly working toward fixing the issue at hand. The other guy might have created the problem, but four months later you’ve either allowed the problem to continue – or you don’t know how to fix it. Obviously something you’re doing isn’t fixing the problem. Does this sound like you? Ask yourself: What am I doing to allow this problem to continue?

Try becoming more consistent in your training. If you’ve got a problem that doesn’t seem to be going away, then when you get on your horse, concentrate more and work harder. Work for improvement. Don’t just kind of hang out and mosey around; stay on the horse as long (or as little) as it takes to see improvement – no matter how small. Drive that horse. Put the head in the same place every time, perfect your circles, get control of the hindquarters. In the example given above (the horse with the stiff neck), you might practice turning your horse, releasing your rein on the turns – and only when the horse drops his head or softens his neck muscles. Whatever, just push and be consistent. If you need a break stop, get off, walk around… but when you get back on the two of you have to get back at it.

Consistency is the answer because teaching the horse one bad thing is the equivalent of teaching the same horse twenty good things. If you release the rein at the wrong time and teach him to pull on the bit, then it’ll take twenty more times of “correct releases” just to get back to where you were. A horse learns a bad habit a heck of a lot quicker than a good one. You can teach any horse to rear up, buck or bite you every time you cinch it up in about ten minutes – but it’ll take two weeks to correct it.

So it’s important that while you’re training (as opposed to out joy riding on the trail), that you stay focused. No matter what, your expectations stay the same (or rise). Why? Because when you are not focused, without even realizing it, you’re allowing the horse to develop bad habits. Maybe you’re doing a circle, you’re talking to your friend and you don’t realize that your horse has begun tugging on the rein, drifting out, pinning his ears at another horse or snatching at grass.

Your horse isn’t a machine. He’s going to have good days and bad days just like you will. Some days you’ll look in the stall and know you shouldn’t go in. Other days will be just great. But in your dealings with your horse, all days need to be treated the same – because it’s consistency that keeps your horse trained and your horsekeeping more enjoyable. Simply put, it’s going to take constant maintenance on your part every day forever. The more consistent you are, the fewer mistakes you’ll teach your horse. The fewer mistakes the horse learns, the quicker you can get onto the trail for the trail rides you’ve earned.

About The Authors

Josh Lyons: One of the most sought-after clinicians in the world, Josh Lyons offers you and your horse a second chance or an enhancement of your existing relationship. His gentle and objective methods, pioneered by his father John Lyons, have helped novice rider and pro alike. Josh continues the “Lyons Legacy,” teaching the John Lyons Certification Program in Parachute, CO and touring often.  He is a frequent contributor to national publications like “Perfect Horse” and “Horse & Rider.” Find out more about Josh Lyons.

Keith Hosman: If your horse won’t speed up, slow down, stop or turn, you missed the latest training methods from Josh and John Lyons.  Have you lost your confidence?  Want a horse to brag about?  Invest one weekend to make big changes with John Lyons Certified Trainer Keith Hosman.  Keith is based near San Antonio, TX and is available for clinics, private sessions and training.  He frequently partners with fellow Certified Trainer Patrick Benson for clinics and demonstrations — with nearly 30 on his 2006 schedule. For more horse training articles, or to attend a clinic or find a John Lyons trainer living in your area, visit horsemanship101.com now.  No part of this article may be reproduced without the express written permission of Josh Lyons and Keith Hosman. 

Keith Hosman

Noted gadabout town and TV writer in his earlier years, Certified John Lyons Trainer Keith Hosman is the author of ten horse-training books published in four languages. He is based in San Antonio, TX and is available for clinics, lessons and training.

Recent Content